Skip to main content

Hypocrisy

There is a fine post at Mode for Caleb on the subject of hypocrisy, and how overuse of this term impairs discussions, especially on the web where anonymity can embolden someone to use rhetorical bombs they might otherwise be more careful about:
Even more importantly, if diagnosing hypocrisy requires knowing motives, the diagnosis cannot be made as a blunt generalization. For example, it certainly may be true that many members of Congress have been putting on a performance with regard to the Schiavo case. But it hardly follows from this that every supporter of Schiavo's parents is hypocritical or insincere. The reverse is also true: if some pro-life protester outside Schiavo's hospice can be proven hypocritical, or even if some Congressional leader dissimulates, neither fact counts as evidence that every member of Congress interested in the case was interested for base reasons. .. I don't want to be mistaken here: I'm not saying that it harms democratic conversation to point out the inconsistencies in a position. But not all inconsistency is hypocritical; people can be unaware of inconsistencies in their positions, while hypocrites are aware of inconsistency but indifferent to it. We are all at various points unaware of inconsistency in our beliefs, and one goal of democratic conversation should be to lead our interlocutors to greater consistency. But when we blanket a position with the charge of hypocrisy, we simply stop at pointing out the inconsistency and attributing it to false motives. Charges of hypocrisy do not move us towards resolving that inconsistency. For example, suppose someone supports preemptive war but also opposes abortion. It could be that this person is a hypocrite, but it could also be that she does not see any inconsistency in her position. In that case, it behooves us to ask her how she makes those positions cohere. If we sense that those positions do not cohere, we ought to offer our reasons for thinking so. But this conversation will be much more difficult if we simply assume -- before the exchange of reasons -- that our interlocutor is wearing a mask, or deliberately hiding bones in a whitewashed tomb.
I've had the very same thought many a time: don't make assumptions about other people's motives, which are always hidden. Doing so is an attempt to control the field of battle and win a battle doomed to be nothing but a clash of empty rhetoric. If you want to explore ideas, especially ideas new and unfamiliar, don't do it. I don't claim to succeed on this all of the time, but I'm aware of it and I'm trying. It's an old idea, by the way. It falls under what Christians would traditionally call basic Charity. Marxists, and schools based on it, tend to dismiss things like Charity as empty bourgesois shells that exist simply to impair those silly enough to think their content is real. The trouble is that if everyone makes the Marxist assumption, dialogue is impossible. Marxism has generated a great deal of literature, however, so what am I talking about? It's simple, really. Such scholars extend a degree of Charity to those they find in some way agreeable. Since only agreeable ideas are accepted, the discussion rapidly becomes inbred and stale, and we wind up with texts like these. I'll never get back the time I wasted as an undergrad, reading Jaques Derrida. Am I a hypocrite for what I just said? No, and here is why. My description of Marxist rhetoric is just that. I have said nothing about why someone might choose to use it or what they hope to gain since, in truth, I don't know. Thanks to Sirius for the link. Also, check out this e-mail graphic icon generator for fooling spambots that I found off Mode for Caleb.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Mirror of the just man

Ecce Homo I haven't done a quote from Pope Ratzinger's Introduction to Chistianty in a while and even though I have finished the book there are still one or two passages I want to share, including - perhaps even especially - this one. When I first began to look over what Christianity teaches, to look at the gospel story and to try penetrate why it has been so compelling to so many for so long, this was one of the things that leapt out at me. I was happy to see our Pope confirm it. Expanding on the Apostles Creed where it says "... suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, died, and was buried," Ratzinger writes: The fact that when the perfectly just man appeared he was crucified, delivered up by justice to death, tells us pitilessly who man is: Thou art such, man, that thou canst not bear the just man - that he who simply loves becomes a fool, a scourged criminal, an outcast. Thou art such because, unjust thyself, thou dost always need the injustice of the n...

Last minute christmas suggestions

Suggestions fror the coming Christmas season: Loreena McKennit , Songs for the Season . Even though McKennit has not released an album in something like a decade, I've only just discovered her and she's amazing. This little EP has only five songs on it and Canadians can pick it up on iTunes for about $4 and change. Amazon wants ten US bucks... Richard Proulx and the Cathedral Singers, Catholic Latin Classics . It's not a Christmas album per se, but it'll sound terrific. Magnificat . This is a really nice daily missal. Fourteen issues a year include two special editions for Holy week and Christmas. Each issue has all of the masses for each day of the month, and a couple of features about historical artworks, poems, and faith issues. These are really nice and I'm glad my wife has deemed me worthy of one.

Redemptionis Sacramentum

Thank you to Rick and Kristina and others who commented on my post about our parish's liturgical meeting this past weekend, and to Tony , who sent a very supportive e-mail. Rick and Kristina pointed me towards a document called Redemptionis Sacramentum , which will be quite helpful, I think. Looking back at the Easter mime incident, for example, I can see issues with Chapter 3, sections 58 to 63. A summary of the document can be found here .