Skip to main content

Bibliophile

I've always taken learning to be almost sacred, scholarship to be transcendent, books sublime. Given this disposition, I was unable to stomach teaching that 20% of my students who were there to get by by hook or by crook (avoid class, avoid the book, succumb to cheating, etc.).
So says Jim Ryan, formerly of the new defunct Philosoblog, and now a Conservative Philosopher contributor, in an exchange with Bill Vallicella. I found this exchange amusing as I felt the same kind of disappointment in my university classes as a student. I had naively hoped to leave that attitude behind when high school was done. Vallicella's comments about text books also rings true:
Most people have no intellectual eros, could not care less about scholarship, and place no value whatsoever on good books. Proof of the latter point can be found by scouring the used bookstores in a locale like Boston-Cambridge. Take a book off the shelf that was assigned in a course, note the underlining or 'magic mark-up' and how it extends maybe three or four pages and then stops -- great for me, of course, who gets a relatively pristine copy for pennies, but indicative of the pointlessness of reading assignments.
A little known fact about me is that when I was a student, I worked in the university bookstore. Partly this was because it was a very convenient place to work, and partly it was because I really liked books. I can verify that what he says is true. It was disappointing to see educated people scorning the fact that they had to buy books in order to take a class. By far the biggest book haters were business students (economists, not so much) and I doubt that fact will surprise anyone. This might, however. The second most common book haters were in the faculty of education. I've heard it said that teachers are often mediocre students. Maybe. I know there's good ones out there. In any case I've always thought that both of those groups would have been better off in a trades school doing more hands on things. The business students, in their defense, were a very high energy bunch. The teachers were impossible know it alls. "Let me tell you how you really should run this bookstore... " Speaking of being in the wrong place - for the last two days a large number of the visitors to NWW have come here after searching for "peeping thong." NWW is not exactly dedicated to the kind of eros you were looking for, eh? Oh well, a few of them seem to have stayed a while and a couple even had nice things to say.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Reuters joins CNN on the bench

Makes room for CanWest to join the majors Kudos to CanWest for calling a terrorist a terrorist . Many, including The Last Amazon , will be happy to hear it. Reuters is among the worst of the major western news services, where I would also place the BBC and the CBC. Unsurprisingly, Reuters is not happy about the changes CanWest made to Reuters wire stories: Our editorial policy is that we don't use emotive words when labeling someone," said David A. Schlesinger, Reuters' global managing editor. "Any paper can change copy and do whatever they want. But if a paper wants to change our copy that way, we would be more comfortable if they remove the byline." Mr. Schlesinger said he was concerned that changes like those made at CanWest could lead to "confusion" about what Reuters is reporting and possibly endanger its reporters in volatile areas or situations. "My goal is to protect

Where credit is due

A good'un from Sawyer Brown . Thank God for You Well I've been called a self-made man Girl don't you believe it's true I know exactly how lucky I am When I'm gettin' this close to you It's high time I'm giving some praise To those that got me where I am today Chorus I got to thank momma for the cookin' Daddy for the whuppin' The devil for the trouble that I get into I got to give credit where credit is due I thank the bank for the money Thank God for you A strong heart and a willing hand That's the secret to my success A good woman - I try to be a good man A good job - Lord I know I've been blessed I'm just a part of a greater plan It doesn't matter which part I am Chorus I got to thank momma for the teachin' Daddy for the preachin' The devil for the trouble that I get into I got to give credit where credit is due I thank the bank for the money Thank God for you

A very limited form of inquiry

Real Clear Politics is carrying commentary on James Q. Wilson's WSJ article on ID (got that?). Wilson, the respected social scientist, gets it mostly right when he says that ID is not science because it can't be tested: So ID is not science. Does this mean that science, in any way, implies the non-existence of God? No. Does this mean that belief in God is irrational and that we should all be "free thinkers"? No. Does this mean that it is impossible to arbitrate between various theories of the existence/non-existence of God and come to some reasonable conclusions? No. Does this mean that we cannot say that humanity is meant to exist? No. In other words, rationality outside of science is quite possible, and has been around for a long time. How do you think humanity invented science in the first place? We surely did not do it scientifically. Science as we know it is the product of millennia of philosophical debate -- from Aristotle to Lakatos. Science depends upon phi